memtest86 +:跟踪奇偶错误,需要精巧的想法


0

好的,我真的希望有个聪明的人会向我提示正确的解决方案。我有一个HP Z420工作站,并且已经升级了内存。我之前有4x4GB,然后又购买了4x4GB。所有8x4GB都相同:“ Samsung 2Rx8 PC3-12800E-11-11-E3”。所以我的主板上有8个DIMM插槽。这些DIMM插槽是双通道的。DIMM插槽1 + 3 + 6 + 8涂成黑色(通道1),DIMM插槽2 + 4 + 5 + 7涂成白色(通道2)。我的旧4x4GB条位于黑色通道1 DIMM插槽内。我将新的4x4GB条形插入白色的通道2 DIMM插槽中。运行memtest时,出现以下消息:

929-Fatal MCA error.
    HA error detected CPU 0 DIMM Slot 5 or 6
    Memory read error - DB parity error

之后,我尝试了不同的配置来跟踪该错误,但是到了死胡同,我需要聪明人的帮助:)这是我的测试摘要的图片,其描述如下: 在此处输入图片说明

Column B: old bars inside the black channel 1, new bars inside the white channel 2. Fails with the message that I have posted earlier.

Column C: testing only the old bars with memtest, it works

Column D: testing only the new bars with memtest, it works. that "4 / 78%" means that I let memtest run until pass 4 at 78% before I stopped it. I forgot to document that at column C.

重要的临时结论:旧的和新的内存条都可以工作!因此,当我混合它们时似乎出现了问题。

Column E: mixing 3 new and 1 old (only black / channel 1): works!

Column F: mixing old and new in dual channel slot 5+6: fails! (forgot to document the slots from the error message though, that's why there's only a red field without description)

Column G: mixing old and new in dual channel slot 3+4: fail!

Column H: mixing old and new in dual channel slot 1+2: fail!

临时想法:在双通道中混合新旧总是失败的,难道是我需要将新旧通道放到自己的双通道中吗?不应有任何区别,因为所有8个钢筋的规格都相同,但看起来确实如此。

Column I: swapping the bars between slot 2 and 3 from column H. So now the new bars are in the same dual channel: works! yay, my theory seems right.

Column J: group the new bars in a dual channel and group the old bars in a dual channel: fails againnnnnnn omg I want to cry ;_;

我的想法用光了,我在错误消息中看不到任何模式。有人有个好主意/评论吗?我的意思是看C和D栏:所有RAM棒都很好!然后我在F列至H列中进行混合,但它们失败了,但是一旦我以“正确的方式”对其进行混合(列I)。但话又回来了(J列)。这是怎么回事,我太笨了:/


您是否考虑过主板不是内存的问题?
Ramhound

每当您填充插槽2或4(属于相同的双通道对)时,都会收到错误消息-这看起来像是死通道。尝试仅填充2和4,如果可以引导,则可以排除它。
Eugen Rieck

@Eugen:F列与该思想相矛盾,其中2和4为空,但错误仍然存​​在:/,我不认为只能加载2和4,因为它们是通道2插槽,应该仅在通道2时才加载1已加载,对吧?
user3182532 '17

@ user3182532 F列是“无引导”条件,没有告诉我们有关通道的任何信息。
Eugen Rieck

您是什么意思,这是“无法启动”状态?它启动了,我能够启动memtest了吗?编辑:哦,您的意思是配置没有告诉我们有关插槽2和4的任何信息?但是我专栏!
user3182532 '17
By using our site, you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Cookie Policy and Privacy Policy.
Licensed under cc by-sa 3.0 with attribution required.