tl; dr：GitEye =最直观的UI，最快的工作流程，高度可定制
我是TortoiseHg Workbench Poweruser的老用户，我喜欢它，因此自然而然地，我完全自以为是的标准主要基于此：
* full history visible in main window
* beautiful tree (DAG), branches CLEARLY separated
* current branch clearly visible in history
* superclear list of changed/added files (list + diff detail)
* each changed/added file can be committed separately (or in groups)
* current branch clearly visible while committing
* clear push/pull etc buttons
* shelve = stash {not to be confused with patches}
* revert
* graft = cherry pick
* max git features
* HiDPI support
* all changes become visible on refresh
* refresh shortcut
我测试了以下应用程序：
- 吉特可乐
- 吉特眼
- 吉特克
- git-gui
- QGit
- 傻笑
- 蒂格
- SmartGit
- gitg
- 兔子VCS
- 吉特·克拉肯
- GitX
- git-dag
- Bazaar Explorer + bzr-git
- TortoiseHg + hggit（最佳用户界面，hggit不起作用）
结果
大多数经过测试的git GUI客户端都是完整的****，以下是2个最佳****，还有1个不如其他****。
传说
- = feature missing or so **** it doesn't count
~ = feature somewhat matches my requirements
+ = feature works like I want :)
第一名：GitEye
最直观的用户界面，最快的工作流程，高度可定制
~ full history visible in main window [in a separate tab, same UI pattern facilitates looking at the history of separate files]
+ beautiful tree (DAG), branches CLEARLY separated
+ current branch clearly visible in history
+ superclear list of changed/added files (list + diff detail)
+ each changed/added file can be committed separately
+ current branch clearly visible while committing
+ clear push/pull etc buttons
+ shelve = stash [Stashes clearly visible in sidepane]
+ revert
+ graft = cherry pick
+ max git features
~ HiDPI support
+ all changes become visible on refresh
- refresh shortcut [you can set one, but it wont work. bug?]
注意：如果Git Files视图停止对您起作用，请使用类似的Git Staging视图。
第二名：SmartGit
漂亮的集成文件比较。提交不清楚，历史隐藏，需要许可证
~ full history visible in main window [separate window, I found myself constantly confusing both windows]
- beautiful tree (DAG), branches CLEARLY separated
- current branch clearly visible in history
+ superclear list of changed/added files (list + diff detail)
~ each changed/added file can be committed separately [UI not clear enough]
- current branch clearly visible while committing
+ clear push/pull etc buttons
+ shelve = stash
+ revert
+ graft = cherry pick
+ max git features
+ HiDPI support
+ all changes become visible on refresh [refreshes automatically]
+ refresh shortcut [refreshes automatically]
第三名：QGit
美丽清晰的历史记录，提交UX混乱，轻巧，可添加自定义命令
+ full history visible in main window
+ beautiful tree (DAG), branches CLEARLY separated
+ current branch clearly visible in history
~ superclear list of changed/added files (list + diff detail) [doesn't show new files in main window]
- each changed/added file can be committed separately
- current branch clearly visible while committing
~ clear push/pull etc buttons [could be added via custom commands]
- shelve = stash
- revert
- graft = cherry pick
- max git features
+ HiDPI support
~ all changes become visible on refresh [except for new files]
+ refresh shortcut
荣誉提名：GitKraken
它仍处于开发阶段（1.5.1仍缺少HiDPI支持），但已完成基本工作。这很容易与GitEye和SmartGit竞争。肯定比QGit好。
其他的：
我对作为git客户端通过的****类型感到失望。我猜他们的作者认为，在命令行上执行日常简单的工作效率更高，他们的客户基于效率低下的工作流程。
git mergetool。我更喜欢将GUI作为mergetool。