空间入侵者的惯用Scala / LWJGL实现看起来不像Haskell / OpenGL实现。在我看来，编写Haskell实现可能是更好的练习。但是，如果您想坚持使用Scala，这里有一些有关如何以功能样式编写它的想法。
尝试仅使用不可变的对象。您可能有一个Game对象，其中包含Player，Set[Invader]（一定要使用immutable.Set）等。给Player一个update(state: Game): Player（它也可以取depressedKeys: Set[Int]等），并为其他类提供类似的方法。
对于随机性，scala.util.Random它不是像Haskell一样不变的System.Random，但是您可以制作自己的不变的生成器。这是低效的，但却说明了这一想法。
case class ImmutablePRNG(val seed: Long) extends Immutable {
lazy val nextLong: (Long, ImmutableRNG) =
(seed, ImmutablePRNG(new Random(seed).nextLong()))
...
}
对于键盘/鼠标输入和渲染，无法调用不纯函数。它们在Haskell中也是不纯的，它们只是封装在IOetc中，因此您的实际函数对象在技术上是纯净的（它们本身不读取或写入状态，它们描述了要执行的例程，并且运行时系统执行了这些例程） 。
只是不要把I / O的代码在你喜欢一成不变的对象Game，Player和Invader。您可以给出Player一个render方法，但是它看起来应该像
render(state: Game, buffer: Image): Image
不幸的是，由于它是基于状态的，因此它不适用于LWJGL，但是您可以在其之上构建自己的抽象。您可能有一个ImmutableCanvas包含AWT 的类Canvas，并且它的blit（和其他方法）可以克隆基础Canvas，将其传递给Display.setParent，然后执行渲染并返回新的Canvas（在不可变的包装器中）。
更新：这是一些Java代码，显示我将如何处理。（我会用Scala编写几乎相同的代码，只是内置了一个不可变的集合，并且可以用地图或折叠代替一些for-each循环。）我做了一个可以四处走动并发射子弹的玩家，但是由于代码已经很长了，所以没有添加敌人。我几乎将所有内容都进行了写时复制 –我认为这是最重要的概念。
import java.awt.*;
import java.awt.geom.*;
import java.awt.image.*;
import java.awt.event.*;
import javax.swing.*;
import java.util.*;
import static java.awt.event.KeyEvent.*;
// An immutable wrapper around a Set. Doesn't implement Set or Collection
// because that would require quite a bit of code.
class ImmutableSet<T> implements Iterable<T> {
final Set<T> backingSet;
// Construct an empty set.
ImmutableSet() {
backingSet = new HashSet<T>();
}
// Copy constructor.
ImmutableSet(ImmutableSet<T> src) {
backingSet = new HashSet<T>(src.backingSet);
}
// Return a new set with an element added.
ImmutableSet<T> plus(T elem) {
ImmutableSet<T> copy = new ImmutableSet<T>(this);
copy.backingSet.add(elem);
return copy;
}
// Return a new set with an element removed.
ImmutableSet<T> minus(T elem) {
ImmutableSet<T> copy = new ImmutableSet<T>(this);
copy.backingSet.remove(elem);
return copy;
}
boolean contains(T elem) {
return backingSet.contains(elem);
}
@Override public Iterator<T> iterator() {
return backingSet.iterator();
}
}
// An immutable, copy-on-write wrapper around BufferedImage.
class ImmutableImage {
final BufferedImage backingImage;
// Construct a blank image.
ImmutableImage(int w, int h) {
backingImage = new BufferedImage(w, h, BufferedImage.TYPE_INT_RGB);
}
// Copy constructor.
ImmutableImage(ImmutableImage src) {
backingImage = new BufferedImage(
src.backingImage.getColorModel(),
src.backingImage.copyData(null),
false, null);
}
// Clear the image.
ImmutableImage clear(Color c) {
ImmutableImage copy = new ImmutableImage(this);
Graphics g = copy.backingImage.getGraphics();
g.setColor(c);
g.fillRect(0, 0, backingImage.getWidth(), backingImage.getHeight());
return copy;
}
// Draw a filled circle.
ImmutableImage fillCircle(int x, int y, int r, Color c) {
ImmutableImage copy = new ImmutableImage(this);
Graphics g = copy.backingImage.getGraphics();
g.setColor(c);
g.fillOval(x - r, y - r, r * 2, r * 2);
return copy;
}
}
// An immutable, copy-on-write object describing the player.
class Player {
final int x, y;
final int ticksUntilFire;
Player(int x, int y, int ticksUntilFire) {
this.x = x;
this.y = y;
this.ticksUntilFire = ticksUntilFire;
}
// Construct a player at the starting position, ready to fire.
Player() {
this(SpaceInvaders.W / 2, SpaceInvaders.H - 50, 0);
}
// Update the game state (repeatedly called for each game tick).
GameState update(GameState currentState) {
// Update the player's position based on which keys are down.
int newX = x;
if (currentState.keyboard.isDown(VK_LEFT) || currentState.keyboard.isDown(VK_A))
newX -= 2;
if (currentState.keyboard.isDown(VK_RIGHT) || currentState.keyboard.isDown(VK_D))
newX += 2;
// Update the time until the player can fire.
int newTicksUntilFire = ticksUntilFire;
if (newTicksUntilFire > 0)
--newTicksUntilFire;
// Replace the old player with an updated player.
Player newPlayer = new Player(newX, y, newTicksUntilFire);
return currentState.setPlayer(newPlayer);
}
// Update the game state in response to a key press.
GameState keyPressed(GameState currentState, int key) {
if (key == VK_SPACE && ticksUntilFire == 0) {
// Fire a bullet.
Bullet b = new Bullet(x, y);
ImmutableSet<Bullet> newBullets = currentState.bullets.plus(b);
currentState = currentState.setBullets(newBullets);
// Make the player wait 25 ticks before firing again.
currentState = currentState.setPlayer(new Player(x, y, 25));
}
return currentState;
}
ImmutableImage render(ImmutableImage img) {
return img.fillCircle(x, y, 20, Color.RED);
}
}
// An immutable, copy-on-write object describing a bullet.
class Bullet {
final int x, y;
static final int radius = 5;
Bullet(int x, int y) {
this.x = x;
this.y = y;
}
// Update the game state (repeatedly called for each game tick).
GameState update(GameState currentState) {
ImmutableSet<Bullet> bullets = currentState.bullets;
bullets = bullets.minus(this);
if (y + radius >= 0)
// Add a copy of the bullet which has moved up the screen slightly.
bullets = bullets.plus(new Bullet(x, y - 5));
return currentState.setBullets(bullets);
}
ImmutableImage render(ImmutableImage img) {
return img.fillCircle(x, y, radius, Color.BLACK);
}
}
// An immutable, copy-on-write snapshot of the keyboard state at some time.
class KeyboardState {
final ImmutableSet<Integer> depressedKeys;
KeyboardState(ImmutableSet<Integer> depressedKeys) {
this.depressedKeys = depressedKeys;
}
KeyboardState() {
this(new ImmutableSet<Integer>());
}
GameState keyPressed(GameState currentState, int key) {
return currentState.setKeyboard(new KeyboardState(depressedKeys.plus(key)));
}
GameState keyReleased(GameState currentState, int key) {
return currentState.setKeyboard(new KeyboardState(depressedKeys.minus(key)));
}
boolean isDown(int key) {
return depressedKeys.contains(key);
}
}
// An immutable, copy-on-write description of the entire game state.
class GameState {
final Player player;
final ImmutableSet<Bullet> bullets;
final KeyboardState keyboard;
GameState(Player player, ImmutableSet<Bullet> bullets, KeyboardState keyboard) {
this.player = player;
this.bullets = bullets;
this.keyboard = keyboard;
}
GameState() {
this(new Player(), new ImmutableSet<Bullet>(), new KeyboardState());
}
GameState setPlayer(Player newPlayer) {
return new GameState(newPlayer, bullets, keyboard);
}
GameState setBullets(ImmutableSet<Bullet> newBullets) {
return new GameState(player, newBullets, keyboard);
}
GameState setKeyboard(KeyboardState newKeyboard) {
return new GameState(player, bullets, newKeyboard);
}
// Update the game state (repeatedly called for each game tick).
GameState update() {
GameState current = this;
current = current.player.update(current);
for (Bullet b : current.bullets)
current = b.update(current);
return current;
}
// Update the game state in response to a key press.
GameState keyPressed(int key) {
GameState current = this;
current = keyboard.keyPressed(current, key);
current = player.keyPressed(current, key);
return current;
}
// Update the game state in response to a key release.
GameState keyReleased(int key) {
GameState current = this;
current = keyboard.keyReleased(current, key);
return current;
}
ImmutableImage render() {
ImmutableImage img = new ImmutableImage(SpaceInvaders.W, SpaceInvaders.H);
img = img.clear(Color.BLUE);
img = player.render(img);
for (Bullet b : bullets)
img = b.render(img);
return img;
}
}
public class SpaceInvaders {
static final int W = 640, H = 480;
static GameState currentState = new GameState();
public static void main(String[] _) {
JFrame frame = new JFrame() {{
setSize(W, H);
setTitle("Space Invaders");
setContentPane(new JPanel() {
@Override public void paintComponent(Graphics g) {
BufferedImage img = SpaceInvaders.currentState.render().backingImage;
((Graphics2D) g).drawRenderedImage(img, new AffineTransform());
}
});
addKeyListener(new KeyAdapter() {
@Override public void keyPressed(KeyEvent e) {
currentState = currentState.keyPressed(e.getKeyCode());
}
@Override public void keyReleased(KeyEvent e) {
currentState = currentState.keyReleased(e.getKeyCode());
}
});
setLocationByPlatform(true);
setDefaultCloseOperation(JFrame.EXIT_ON_CLOSE);
setVisible(true);
}};
for (;;) {
currentState = currentState.update();
frame.repaint();
try {
Thread.sleep(20);
} catch (InterruptedException e) {}
}
}
}